|
We have sworn to you once,
But now we make our allegiance permanent.
Like currents in a torrent lost,
We all flow into you.
Even when we cannot understand you,
We will go with you.
One day we may comprehend,
How you can see our future.
Hearts like bronze shields,
We have placed around you,
And it seems to us, that only
You can reveal God's world to us.
|
This poem ran in an in-house magazine
published by Ford Motor Company's German subsidiary in April of 1940.
Titled "Fuehrer," the poem appeared at a time when Ford maintained complete
control of the German company and two of its top executives sat on the
subsidiary's board. It was also a time when the object of Ford's affection
was in the process of overrunning Western Europe after already having
swallowed up Austria, Czechoslovakia and Poland in the East
I found "Fuehrer" among thousands
of pages of documents compiled by the Washington law firm of Cohen,
Milstein, Hausfeld & Toll, which sought damages from Ford on behalf
of a Russian woman who toiled as a slave laborer at its German plant.
This past September, a judge in New Jersey, Joseph Greenaway Jr., threw
the case out on the grounds that the statute of limitations had expired.
Greenaway, who did not exonerate Ford, did accept the company's argument
that "redressing the tragedies of that period has been--and should continue
to be--a nation-to-nation, government-to-government concern."
Ford argues that company headquarters
in Dearborn, Michigan, lost control of its German plant after the United
States entered the war in 1941. Hence, Ford is not responsible for any
actions taken by its German subsidiary during World War II. "We did
not do business in Germany during the war," says Lydia Cisaruk, a Ford
spokeswoman. "The Nazis confiscated the plant there and we lost all
contact." She added that Ford played a "pivotal role in the American
war effort. After the United States entered the war, Ford threw its
entire backing to the war effort."
That Ford and a number of other American
firms--including General Motors and Chase Manhattan--worked with the
Nazis has been previously disclosed. So, too, has Henry Ford's role
as a leader of the America First Committee, which sought to keep the
United States out of World War II. However, the new materials, most
of which were found at the National Archives, are far more damning than
earlier revelations. They show, among other things, that up until Pearl
Harbor, Dearborn made huge revenues by producing war matériel
for the Reich and that the man it selected to run its German subsidiary
was an enthusiastic backer of Hitler. German Ford served as an "arsenal
of Nazism" with the consent of headquarters in Dearborn, says a US Army
report prepared in 1945
Moreover, Ford's cooperation with
the Nazis continued until at least August 1942--eight months after the
United States entered the war--through its properties in Vichy France.
Indeed, a secret wartime report prepared by the US Treasury Department
concluded that the Ford family sought to further its business interests
by encouraging Ford of France executives to work with German officials
overseeing the occupation. "There would seem to be at least a tacit
acceptance by [Henry Ford's son] Mr. Edsel Ford of the reliance...on
the known neutrality of the Ford family as a basis of receipt of favors
from the German Reich," it says .
The new information about Ford's World
War II role comes at a time of growing attention to corporate collaboration
with the Third Reich. In 1998 Swiss banks reached a settlement with
Holocaust survivors and agreed to pay $1.25 billion. That set the stage
for a host of new Holocaust-related revelations as well as legal claims
stemming from such issues as looted art and unpaid insurance benefits.
This past November NBC News reported that Chase Manhattan's French branch
froze Jewish accounts at the request of German occupation authorities.
Chase's Paris branch manager, Carlos Niedermann, worked closely with
German officials and approved loans to finance war production for the
Nazi Army. In Germany the government and about fifty firms that employed
slave and forced labor during World War II--including Bayer, BMW, Volkswagen
and Daimler-Chrysler--reached agreement in mid-December to establish
a $5.1 billion fund to pay victims. Opel, General Motors' German subsidiary,
announced it would contribute to the fund. (As reported last year in
the "Washington Post", an FBI report from 1941 quoted James Mooney,
GM's director of overseas operations, as saying he would refuse to do
anything that might "make Hitler mad.") Ford refused to participate
in the settlement talks, though its collaboration with the Third Reich
was egregious and extensive. Ford's director of global operations, Jim
Vella, said in a statement, "Because Ford did not do business in Germany
during the war--our Cologne plant was confiscated by the Nazi government--it
would be inappropriate for Ford to participate in such a fund."
The generous treatment allotted Ford
Motor by the Nazi regime is partially attributable to the violent anti-Semitism
of the company's founder, Henry Ford. His pamphlet "The International
Jew: The World's Foremost Problem"brought him to the attention of a
former German Army corporal named Adolf Hitler, who in 1923 became chairman
of the fledgling Nazi Party. When Ford was considering a run for the
presidency that year, Hitler told the "Chicago Tribune", "I wish that
I could send some of my shock troops to Chicago and other big American
cities to help." (The story comes from Charles Higham's "Trading With
the Enemy", which details American business collaboration with the Nazis.)
In "Mein Kampf", written two years later, Hitler singled Ford out for
praise. "It is Jews who govern the stock exchange forces of the American
Union," he wrote. "Every year makes them more and more the controlling
masters of the producers in a nation of one hundred and twenty millions;
only a single great man, Ford, to their fury, still maintains full independence."
In 1938, long after the vicious character of Hitler's government had
become clear, Ford accepted the Grand Cross of the German Eagle, the
Nazi regime's highest honor for foreigners .
Ford Motor set up shop in Germany
in 1925, when it opened an office in Berlin. Six years later, it built
a large plant in Cologne, which became its headquarters in the country.
Ford of Germany prospered during the Nazi years, especially with the
economic boom brought on by World War II. Sales increased by more than
half between 1938 and 1943, and, according to a US government report
found at the National Archives, the value of the German subsidiary more
than doubled during the course of the war
Ford eagerly collaborated with the
Nazis, which greatly enhanced its business prospects and at the same
time helped Hitler prepare for war (and after the 1939 invasion of Poland,
conduct it). In the mid-thirties, Dearborn helped boost German Ford's
profits by placing orders with the Cologne plant for direct delivery
to Ford plants in Latin America and Japan. In 1936, as a means of preserving
the Reich's foreign reserves, the Nazi government blocked the German
subsidiary from buying needed raw materials. Ford headquarters in Dearborn
responded--just as the Nazis hoped it would--by shipping rubber and
other materials to Cologne in exchange for German-made parts. The Nazi
government took a 25 percent cut out of the imported raw materials and
gave them to other manufacturers, an arrangement approved by Dearborn
According to the US Army report of
1945, prepared by Henry Schneider, German Ford began producing vehicles
of a strictly military nature for the Reich even before the war began.
The company also established a war plant ready for mobilization day
in a "'safe' zone" near Berlin, a step taken, according to Schneider,
"with the...approval of Dearborn." Following Hitler's 1939 invasion
of Poland, which set off World War II, German Ford became one of the
largest suppliers of vehicles to the Wehrmacht (the German Army). Papers
found at the National Archives show that the company was selling to
the SS and the police as well. By 1941 Ford of Germany had stopped manufacturing
passenger vehicles and was devoting its entire production capacity to
military trucks. That May the leader of the Nazi Party in Cologne sent
a letter to the plant thanking its leaders for helping "assure us victory
in the present [war] struggle" and for demonstrating the willingness
to "cooperate in the establishment of an exemplary social state."
Ford vehicles were crucial to the
revolutionary Nazi military strategy of blitzkrieg. Of the 350,000 trucks
used by the motorized German Army as of 1942, roughly one-third were
Ford-made. The Schneider report states that when American troops reached
the European theater, "Ford trucks prominently present in the supply
lines of the Wehrmacht were understandably an unpleasant sight to men
in our Army." Indeed, the Cologne plant proved to be so important to
the Reich's war effort that the Allies bombed it on several occasions.
A secret 1944 US Air Force "Target Information Sheet" on the factory
said that for the previous five years it had been "geared for war production
on a high level."
While Ford Motor enthusiastically
worked for the Reich, the company initially resisted calls from President
Roosevelt and British Prime Minister Churchill to increase war production
for the Allies. The Nazi government was grateful for that stance, as
acknowledged in a letter from Heinrich Albert to Charles Sorenson, a
top executive in Dearborn. Albert had been a lawyer for German Ford
since at least 1927, a director since 1930 and, according to the Treasury
report, part of a German espionage ring operating in the United States
during World War I. "The 'Dementi' of Mr. Henry Ford concerning war
orders for Great Britain has greatly helped us," Albert wrote in July
of 1940, shortly after the fall of France, when England appeared to
be on the verge of collapse before the Fuehrer's troops
Ford's energetic cooperation with
the Third Reich did not prevent the company's competitors from seeking
to tarnish it by calling attention to its non-German ownership. Ford
responded by appointing a majority-German board of directors for the
Cologne plant, upon which it bestowed the politically correct Aryan
name of Ford Werke. In March of 1941, Ford issued new stock in the Cologne
plant and sold it exclusively to Germans, thereby reducing Dearborn's
share to 52 percent
At the time, the Nazi government's
Ministry of Economy debated whether the opportunity afforded by the
capital increase should be taken to demand a German majority at Ford
Werke. The Ministry "gave up the idea"--this according to a 1942 statement
prepared by a Ford Werke executive--in part because "there could be
no doubt about the complete incorporation, as regards personnel, organization
and production system, of Ford Werke into the German national economy,
in particular, into the German armaments industry." Beyond that, Albert
argued in a letter to the Reich Commission for Enemy Property, the abolition
of the American majority would eliminate "the importance of the company
for the obtaining of raw materials," as well as "insight into American
production and sales methods." .
As 1941 progressed, the board of Ford
Werke fretted that the United States would enter the war in support
of Britain and the government would confiscate the Cologne plant. To
prevent such an outcome, the Cologne management wrote to the Reich Commission
that year to say that it "question[ed] whether Ford must be treated
as enemy property" even in the event of a US declaration of war on Germany.
"Ford has become a purely German company and has taken over all obligations
so successfully that the American majority shareholder, independent
of the favorable political views of Henry Ford, in some periods actually
contributed to the development of German industry," Cologne argued on
June 18, 1941, only six months before the bombing of Pearl Harbor
In May of 1942, the Superior Court
of Cologne finally put Ford Werke in "trusteeship," ruling that it was
"under authoritative enemy influence." However, the Nazis never nationalized
Ford's German property--plant managers feared it would be turned over
to Mercedes or the Hermann Goering Werke, a huge industrial network
composed of properties seized by the Reich--and Dearborn maintained
its 52 percent share through the duration of the war. Ford Werke even
set aside dividend payments due to Dearborn, which were paid after the
war. Ford claims that it received only $60,000 in dividend payments.
It's not possible to independently verify that--or anything else regarding
Dearborn's wartime economic relationship with Cologne--because Ford
of America was privately held until 1956, and the company will not make
available its balance sheets from the period
Labor shortages caused by the war--millions
of men were at the front and Nazi ideology was violently opposed to
the idea of women working--led the Reich to deport millions of people
from occupied lands to Germany to work in factories. German companies
were encouraged to bid for forced laborers in order to meet production
quotas and increase profits. By 1943 half of Ford Werke's work force
comprised foreign captives, including French, Russians, Ukrainians and
Belgians. In August of 1944 a squad of SS men brought fifteen prisoners
from the Buchenwald concentration camp to Ford Werke. The German researcher
Karola Fings, co-author of "Working for the Enemy", a book on Nazi slave-
and forced-labor programs, to be published this spring, says Ford's
worker-inmates toiled for twelve hours a day with a fifteen-minute break.
They were given 200 grams of bread and coffee for breakfast, no lunch
and a dinner of spinach and three potatoes or soup made of turnip leaves
.
An account by Robert Schmidt, the
man appointed to run Ford Werke in 1939, states that the company used
forced laborers even before the Nazis put the plant in trusteeship.
His statement, sent to a Ford executive in England immediately after
Germany's surrender, says that as of 1940 "many of our employees were
called to the colours and had to be replaced by whatever was available....
The same applies to 1941. Some 200 French prisoners of war were employed."
In a statement to the US Army in 1945, Schmidt said that the Gestapo
began to play an important role at Ford Werke after the first foreign
workers arrived. With the assistance of W.M. Buchwald, a Ford employee
since the mid-thirties, the Gestapo carefully monitored plant activities.
"Whenever there was the slightest indication of anti-Nazi feeling, be
it amongst foreigners or Germans, the Gestapo tramped down as hard as
possible," Schmidt told the Army
Meanwhile, Ford Werke offered enthusiastic
political support for Hitler as well. The fraternal ties between Ford
and the Nazis is perhaps best symbolized by the company's birthday gift
to the Fuehrer of 35,000 Reichsmarks in April of 1939. Ford Werke's
in-house publication couldn't have been more fanatically pro-Nazi if
Josef Goebbels had edited it. "Fuehrer," the poem printed at the top
of this story, ran in the April 1940 issue, which celebrated Hitler's
51st birthday by running his picture on the cover. The issue carried
an excerpt of a speech by Hitler in which he declared that "by natural
law of the earth, we are the supreme race and thus destined to rule."
In another section of the speech, the Fuehrer declared that communism
was "second in wretchedness only to Judaism." The issue from April of
the following year--this at roughly the high point of the Third Reich's
military victories--featured a photograph of a beaming Hitler visiting
with German soldiers on the front lines. "The management of the Ford-Werke
salutes our Fuehrer with grateful heart, honesty, and allegiance, and--as
before--pledges to cooperate in his life's work: achieving honor, liberty
and happiness for Greater Germany and, indeed, for all peoples of Europe,"
reads the caption
Robert Schmidt so successfully converted
the plant to a war footing that the Nazi regime gave him the title of
"WehrwirtschaftsFuehrer", or Military Economic Leader. The Nazis also
put Schmidt in charge of overseeing Ford plants in occupied Belgium,
Holland and Vichy France. At one point, he and another Cologne executive
bitterly argued over who would run Ford of England when Hitler's troops
conquered Britain
Schmidt's personal contributions to
Ford Werke's in-house organ reflect his ardently pro-Nazi views. "At
the beginning of this year we vowed to give our best and utmost for
final victory, in unshakable faithfulness to our Fuehrer," he wrote
in December of 1941, the same month as Pearl Harbor. "Today we say with
pride that we succeeded if not in reaching all our goals, nevertheless
in contributing to a considerable extent in providing the necessary
transportation for our troops at the front." The following March, Schmidt
penned an article in which he declared, "It depends upon our work whether
the front can be supplied with its necessities.... therefore, we too
are soldiers of the Fuhrer." .
The Ford family and company executives
in Dearborn repeatedly congratulated the management of Ford Werke on
the fine work they were doing under the Nazis. In October of 1940 Edsel
Ford wrote to Heinrich Albert to say how pleased he was that the company's
plants in occupied lands were continuing to operate. "It is fortunate
that Mr. Schmidt is in such authority as to be able to bring out these
arrangements," said Edsel, who died of cancer during the war. The same
letter indicates that Ford was quite prepared to do business with the
Nazis if Hitler won the war. Though it was difficult to foresee what
would happen after the fighting ended, Edsel told Albert, "a general
rearrangement of the ownership of our continental businesses may be
required. You will no doubt keep as close to this subject as possible
and we will have the benefit of your thoughts and suggestions at the
proper time."
"To know that you appreciate our efforts
in your and the company's interests is certainly a great encouragement,"
Albert replied the following month. He went on to praise Schmidt, who
had been forced to shoulder immense responsibilities after war broke
out. "In fulfilling his task his personality has grown in a way which
is almost astonishing." Indeed, Schmidt grew to such a great degree
that the Nazis kept him in charge of Ford Werke after they put the company
in trusteeship. In February of 1942, when the question of who would
run the Cologne plant was still up in the air, a local Nazi official
wrote to Hitler's Chancellery in Berlin to put in a good word for Ford's
man. The official said he saw "no reason to appoint a special custodian
for the enterprise" since Schmidt was "a Party member [who] enjoys my
confidence and...the confidence of the German Armed Forces." .
Ford's behavior in France following
the German occupation of June 1940 illustrates even more grotesquely
its collaborationist posture. As soon as the smoke had cleared, Ford's
local managers cut a deal with the occupation authorities that allowed
the company to resume production swiftly--"solely for the benefit of
Germany and the countries under its [rule]," according to a US Treasury
Department document. The report, triggered by the government's concern
that Ford was trading with the enemy, is sharply critical of Maurice
Dollfus, a Ford director in France since 1929 and the company's manager
during the Vichy period. "Mr. Dollfus was required by law to replace
directors, and he selected the new directors exclusively from the ranks
of prominent collaborationists," says the Treasury report. "Mr. Dollfus
did this deliberately to curry favor with the authorities." The report
refers to another Ford employee, a certain Amable Roger Messis, as "100%
pro-German."
The Treasury Department found that
Ford headquarters in Dearborn was in regular contact with its properties
in Vichy France. In one letter, penned shortly after France's surrender,
Dollfus assured Dearborn that "we will benefit from the main fact of
being a member of the Ford family which entitles us to better treatment
from our German colleagues who have shown clearly their wish to protect
the Ford interest as much as they can." A Ford executive in Michigan
wrote back, "We are pleased to learn from your letter...that our organization
is going along, and the victors are so tolerant in their treatment.
It looks as though we still might have a business that we can carry
on in spite of all the difficulties."
The Ford family encouraged Dollfus
to work closely with the German authorities. On this score, Dollfus
needed little prodding. "In order to safeguard our interests--and I
am here talking in a very broad way--I have been to Berlin and have
seen General von Schell himself," he wrote in a typed note to Edsel
in August of 1940. "My interview with him has been by all means satisfactory,
and the attitude you have taken together with your father of strict
neutrality has been an invaluable asset for the protection of your companies
in Europe." (In a handwritten note in the margin, Dollfus bragged that
he was "the first Frenchman to go to Berlin.") The following month Dollfus
complained about a shortage of dollars in occupied France. This was
a problem, however, that might be merely temporary. "As you know," he
wrote Dearborn at the time, "our [monetary] standard has been replaced
by another standard which--in my opinion--is a draft on the future,
not only in France and Europe but, maybe, in the world." In another
letter to Edsel, this one written in late November of 1940, Dollfus
said he wanted to "outline the importance attached by high officials
to respect the desires and maintain the good will of 'Ford'--and by
'Ford' I mean your father, yourself and the Ford Motor Company, Dearborn."
All this was to the immense satisfaction
of the Ford family. In October of 1940, Edsel wrote to Dollfus to say
he was "delighted to hear you are making progress.... Fully realize
great handicap you are working under." Three months later he wrote again
to say that Ford headquarters was "very proud of the record that you
and your associates have made in building the company up to its first
great position under such circumstances."
Dearborn maintained its communication
with Ford of France well after the United States entered the war. In
late January of 1942, Dollfus informed Dearborn that Ford's operations
had the highest production level of all French manufacturers and, as
summed up by the Treasury report, that he was "still relying on the
French government to preserve the interests of American stockholders."
During the following months, Dollfus
wrote to Edsel several times to report on damages suffered by the French
plant during bombing runs by the Royal Air Force. In his reply, Edsel
expressed relief that American newspapers that ran pictures of a burning
Ford factory did not identify it as a company property. On July 17,
1942, Edsel wrote again to say that he had shown Dollfus's most recent
letter to his father and to Dearborn executive Sorenson. "They both
join me in sending best wishes for you and your staff, and the hope
that you will continue to carry on the good work that you are doing,"
he said
As in Germany, Ford's policy of sleeping
with the Nazis proved to be a highly lucrative approach. Ford of France
had never been very profitable in peacetime--it had paid out only one
dividend in its history--but its service to the Third Reich soon pushed
it comfortably into the black. Dollfus once wrote to Dearborn to boast
about this happy turn of events, adding that the company's "prestige
in France has increased considerably and is now greater than it was
before the war." .
Treasury Department officials were
clearly aghast at Ford's activities. An employee named Randolph Paul
sent the report to Secretary Henry Morgenthau with a note that stated,
"The increased activity of the French Ford subsidiaries on behalf of
the Germans received the commendation of the Ford family in America."
Morgenthau soon replied, "If we can legally and ethically do it, I would
like to turn over the information in connection with the Ford Motor
Company to Senator [Harry] Truman."
Lydia Cisaruk, the Ford spokeswoman,
says that Ford Werke's pre-Pearl Harbor support for the Third Reich
was largely unknown to company headquarters. Neither of the two Dearborn
executives on Ford Werke's board, Edsel Ford and Charles Sorenson, attended
board meetings after 1938. "By 1940, Dearborn was becoming less and
less involved in day-to-day operations," she says. "There was a gradual
loss of control." Asked about Ford Werke's political support for the
Nazis, as seen in its in-house newsletter, she replied: "Looking at
the years leading up to the war, no one could foresee what was going
to happen. A number of countries were negotiating with Germany and Germany
was repeatedly saying that it was interested in peaceful solutions.
The United States was talking to Germany until the two countries went
to war." She concedes that some "foreign" labor was employed at the
plant beginning in 1940, but says Dearborn had no knowledge of that
at the time. Ford is currently conducting an exhaustive investigation
into Ford Werke, she says. When the research is completed this year,
the company will make available all of the documentary evidence it has
accumulated, including financial records. While Ford did not take part
in the German slave-labor talks, Cisaruk says it is in preliminary discussions
with Deputy Treasury Secretary Stuart Eizenstat to establish a humanitarian
US-based fund for Holocaust survivors. "We do want to help people who
suffered at the hands of the Nazis," she says .
Production at Ford Werke slowed at
the end of the war, in part because of power shortages caused by Allied
bombing runs, but activity never came to a halt. Soon after Germany's
capitulation, Ford representatives from England and the United States
traveled to Cologne to inspect the plant and plan for the future. In
1948 Henry Ford visited Cologne to celebrate the 10,000th truck to roll
off the postwar assembly line there. Two years later, Ford of Germany
rehired Schmidt--who had been arrested and briefly held by US troops
at the war's end--after he wrote a letter to Dearborn in which he insisted
that he had fervently hated the Nazis. He was one of six key executives
from the Nazi era who moved back into important positions at Ford after
1945. "After the war, Ford did not just reassume control of a factory,
but it also took over the factory's history," says historian Fings.
"Apparently no one at Ford was interested in casting light upon this
part of history, not even to explicitly proclaim a distance from the
practices of Ford Werke during the Nazi era." Schmidt remained with
Ford until his death in 1962
The high point of Ford's cynicism
was yet to come. Before its fall, the Nazi regime had given Ford Werke
about $104,000 in compensation for damages caused by Allied bombings
(Ford also got money for bombing damages from the Vichy government).
Dearborn was not satisfied with that amount. In 1965 Ford went before
the Foreign Claims Settlement Commission of the US to ask for an additional
$7 million. (During the hearings, commission attorney Zvonko Rode pointed
to the embarrassing fact--which Ford's attorney did not dispute--that
most of the manufactured products destroyed during the bombings had
been intended for the use of the Nazi armed forces.) In the end, the
commission awarded the company $1.1 million--but only after determining
that Ford had used a fraudulent exchange rate to jack up the size of
the alleged damages. The commission also found that Dearborn had sought
compensation for merchandise that had been destroyed by flooding
Ford's eagerness to be compensated
for damages incurred to Ford Werke during the Nazi era makes its current
posture of denying any association with the wartime plant all the more
hypocritical. These new revelations may force Ford to reconsider its
responsibilities with regard to slave labor. In the meantime, new legal
developments could also create problems for the company. Last year California
passed a law that extends the statute of limitations on Holocaust-related
claims. In November Senator Charles Schumer of New York introduced a
bill in Congress that would do the same thing at the federal level.
|